Who are the Most Hardcore Fans in New York? Jets, Giants or Bills?

There are 3 NFL teams with either “New York” in the name or a city from the state. But which team has the most hardcore fans in New York?

BetMGM Sports

BetMGM Sports SPECIAL OFFER

Bet $10, Get $200 instantly in Bonus Bets!
Bet $10, Get $200 Get Bonus
Terms and conditions apply

The Empire State is one the most populated states in the United States, with nearly 20 million people.

New York City is one of the world’s most famous cities belonging to the state. You’ll find the 27-time World Series Champion New York Yankees in that city, the Statue of Liberty, Ellis Island, and so much more.

Three NFL teams have either “New York” in the name or a city from the state:

  1. New York Giants
  2. New York Jets
  3. Buffalo Bills

Interestingly enough, though, the two New York teams aren’t located in New York. Instead, they’re located close by in East Rutherford, New Jersey, and share the same stadium.

The Bills are located more north and close to Canada up in Buffalo.

FanDuel Sports

FanDuel Sports SPECIAL OFFER

Bet $5 and get $200 back in bonus bets PLUS a $100 discount code for NFL Sunday ticket on Youtube TV.
Bet $5, Get $200 Get Bonus
Terms and conditions apply

But that doesn’t mean there is no rivalry there. Just look at the Steelers and Eagles in Pittsburgh and Philadelphia, respectively. Their stadiums are almost 500km apart, but they both belong to Pennsylvania.

With three teams representing New York and all having storied histories and accomplishments over the years, who has the most hardcore fans in New York?

Let’s start in the north with Bills Mafia.

Buffalo Bills

The most well-known fan base in the NFL is Bills Mafia, hands down.

While not all fans participate in the antics, this is what they’re referred to as a collective group.

Before games, Bills Mafia will tailgate hours before the game and not only drink themselves into a drunken stupor but take it another level by hosting their WWE-like events, jumping through and putting each other through tables.

Now a Bills game is one I’ve attended in person—as a fan of another team.

It’s like it was yesterday—Ravens wide receiver Torrey Smith returned a kickoff for a touchdown. Jumping up in excitement for my team was not well met by some of the fans who proceeded to lunge aluminum beer cans toward my head.

Thankfully managing to escape unscathed by the cans. That experience reiterated to me that Bills fans are hardcore.

There have been individual reports of violence like with any fans. But Bills fans are what we’d call a “rare breed”.

There are violent tendencies, but Bills fans are mostly obnoxious and meme-worthy. Making them worthy of a spot on the list of One of the most hardcore fans in New York.

Caesars Sports

Caesars Sports SPECIAL OFFER

Use promo code ‘EXPERTVIP1000’ and receive up to a $1,000 Bonus Bet if your first real-money bet loses.
$1,000 on Caesars Get Bonus
EXPERTVIP1000
Terms and conditions apply

New York Giants

It’s been tough sleddin’ for Giants fans since the glory days with Eli Manning beating the New England Patriots in 2004 and 2007.

Since then, there haven’t been many stories that point to Giants fans as being overly violent or rude. They’re not one of the most hardcore fans in New York, but rather something different.

According to World Sports Network, Giants fans rank as the most pessimistic fan base.

Most Passionate Fans in New York

The study was performed using SentiStrength, which “measures the tone of a short piece of text and categorizes it as either positive, neutral, or negative.”

This makes sense. There’s been a lack of organizational structure with poor general management and head coaching. Heading into 2022, it should be better with new head coach Brian Daboll from the Bills and Joe Schoen as general manager.

The Giants drafted Daniel Jones with the No. 6 overall pick in 2019. This was commonly looked at as a reach, and the results have not lived up to expectations.

The 2022 season could be Jones’ last in New York if he doesn’t perform, adding to the negativity from Giants fans.

New York Jets

Although the Giants dawn the same “New York” in their name and share a stadium, it seems the stereotypical New Yorker is more like a Jets fan.

The Jets haven’t won a Super Bowl since 1969 with Joe Namath. Since then, there has been some success, including years with Mark Sanchez as the quarterback and Rex Ryan as head coach.

Are Jets Fans Loyal

New Yorkers are somewhat abrasive, but the Jets haven’t been good in some time.

Since 2010, the Jets have only had two winning seasons and two seasons finishing 8-8. The rest were all losing seasons, with the lowest win total coming in 2020, going 2-14.

So, while there may be that arrogance from the average fan, there’s nothing to back it up due to the team’s struggles. Definitely not one of the most hardcore fans in New York.

Most Hardcore Fans in New York: Bills, Giants, or Jets?

While Bills Mafia is more prone to throw an aluminum beer bottle at your head, they also create some of the most viral and hilarious sports content. And, let’s be honest, they’re a very passionate bunch.

When compared to Jets and Giants fans, who are just negative fans with hints of arrogance, there’s not much to go off there.

Bills Mafia wins this battle of most hardcore fans in New York, and they’re by far the best team of the bunch.

BetMGM Sports

BetMGM Sports SPECIAL OFFER

Bet $10, Get $200 instantly in Bonus Bets!
Bet $10, Get $200 Get Bonus
Terms and conditions apply
Caesars Sports

Caesars Sports SPECIAL OFFER

Use promo code ‘EXPERTVIP1000’ and receive up to a $1,000 Bonus Bet if your first real-money bet loses.
$1,000 on Caesars Get Bonus
EXPERTVIP1000
Terms and conditions apply
DraftKings Sports

DraftKings Sports SPECIAL OFFER

Join DraftKings and bet $5+ on any pre-game moneyline. Win $200 in Bonus Bets if your bet wins!
Bet $5, Get $200 Get Bonus
Terms and conditions apply
FanDuel Sports

FanDuel Sports SPECIAL OFFER

Bet $5 and get $200 back in bonus bets PLUS a $100 discount code for NFL Sunday ticket on Youtube TV.
Bet $5, Get $200 Get Bonus
Terms and conditions apply
BetRivers Sports

BetRivers Sports SECOND CHANCE

Join BetRivers and get a 2nd Chance Bet up to $250.
$250 2nd Chance Bet Get Bonus
Terms and conditions apply

Latest Offers

Latest News

The Question Everyone is Asking Themselves…Can I Bet on Pickleball?

Surprisingly, the fastest growing sport right now is Pickleball. That means more and more people are looking to place bets on it.

More Articles Like This